Why I Went from a Jon & Kate Plus 8 Supporter to a Disenchanted Viewer

Jon and Kate Gosselin Should Not Deceive the Public

Donna H. Davey
It wasn't so long ago I wrote a piece entitled, "Jon & Kate plus 8: At Least They're Genuine." Well, I was wrong. It just took a while to see it because I generally want to believe the best in people.

I wanted to like Jon and Kate Gosselin. I wanted to believe their story and I found the idea of this young couple with several children trying to budget and get by rather inspiring. Little did I know I was being deceived, or rather, the public was being deceived.

I have watched every episode, and at the inception I was one of Jon and Kate's many supporters and defenders. I never thought people were jealous of them, but I did think their detractors were pretty hateful and I even started writing an article about those hateful people.

And then...as each episode aired I became increasingly troubled. At first Kate's treatment of Jon didn't seem so bad, in fact, during the early years of my marriage I had a tendency to be demanding but seeing myself on home video changed things completely. I couldn't stand what I was and I changed for the better. I also apologized to my husband, and meant it.

Light-hearted teasing between spouses can be fun on some level, but when it becomes criticism cloaked beneath playful banter it becomes disrespectful and unkind. Kate continually harps on Jon but I don't imagine it would be well received in return. Even more so would be the infamous "love taps." How would she react if he was continually yelling for her to do everything? Unfortunately, even now I can hear her bellow his name.

I've also been disturbed by the obvious favoritism of the girls, and the heartbreaking treatment of little Joel. I didn't want to believe it; I didn't want to see it. I really wanted to like Jon and Kate.

In the most recent episode, Kate coldly, yes, coldly, dismissed Joel after he asked to help decorate a cake, but Kate happily let all the girls participate and even brought out her camera to capture the moment on film. While they were smiling, Joel walked off by himself. It was not an isolated incident, although I wish it were.

Other than the favoritism, I couldn't understand why Kate refused to let the children have fun, and sometimes fun means getting messy.

Now I know why...Kate receives free clothing from sponsors and she consigns the clothing for top dollar; top dollar means receiving clothes that are "gently used."

I believe that fun memories and a carefree childhood are more important than worrying about what kind of stains get on clothing, especially clothes that were given free of charge. They are only young once, let them scamper, cavort and get dirty.

And that brings me to the freebies...

I'm around the same age as Kate, but I was raised to believe that the world owes me nothing, and that a sense of entitlement is a terrible, selfish thing to have. I'm free to make my choices in life but society doesn't owe me for those choices.

I fully understand the generosity and kindness of those that have donated to the Gosselin's. What I find offensive is that Jon and Kate deceive the public into believing they still need and deserve all the freebies. They expect them and they are not truthful about the help they receive.

They once claimed that they would donate what was donated to them. They haven't. They've sold them.

They do not let the public know that they have been given a chef who cooks them organic meals every day (according to one source). Kate has someone do her laundry, and now some of her cooking. Jon takes care of the children and they also have a nanny, nicely referred to as a "helper." But Kate is always exhausted...

Their website still claims there are no college funds set up for their children but according to the state of PA, one was set up shortly after the children were born. Having said that, why does the public owe their children a college education? Many people pay their own way through college and do quite nicely. Self-sufficiency is an admirable trait to have.

Neighbors have claimed that when Kate received her free tummy tuck that many meals were cooked and delivered to the Gosselins but that generosity was never mentioned in the show. Those same neighbors say that Kate has always been rude and dismissive towards them, even when help has been given.

Kate has alienated her family. Have you noticed the lack of Jodi's presence on the show? Apparently TLC was going to compensate Jodi financially for being a "regular," but Kate would not allow it. That's when the show hired the new nanny. Evidently Kate thinks its okay to pay an outsider, but God forbid a family member be compensated for her appearances. And let it be known, Jodi didn't care about the money. Jodi's sister has a blog called, "Truth Breeds Hatred." One of her posts has a short video clip of Jodi thanking the public for being so supportive of her. Jodi, kind sweet Jodi - the kind of Aunt I wish my kids had - hasn't seen her nieces and nephews in months. That's the kind of thanks she gets from Jon and Kate for being such a help and support to them all these years. Who can forget her watching her own four children, plus her eight nieces and nephews - all of whom were really sick - so Kate could accompany Jon when he flew to CA for a free hair transplant? Has Kate ever watched Jodi's kids?

And where is Beth Carson? The wonderful friend I wrote about in one of my previous articles? It seems she was alienated for the same reason as Jodi was. Remarkable people such as Jodi and Beth do not come into people's lives easily - some can only dream about having family and friends like that - but Kate couldn't even give back or nourish those relationships, which I find tragic.

A home is being built for Jon and Kate, rumor has it that it's being built in NC, and is 8,000 square feet with a pool house. According to a family member, sponsors are donating furniture and appliances.

Jon does not work outside of the home. Neither does Kate. Normally I wouldn't find that a negative if they in fact earned their way, but they are living off their kids and I find that objectionable. We are allowed a glimpse into their lives on a weekly basis. How much camera time and re-shoots do those children have to endure to make up one episode? According to those that are privy, a lot. They also have permanent cameras in their rooms and studio lighting. Those children are working but have no protection. They are also subjected to situations that could be humiliating for them in years to come. I know I wouldn't be happy if my childhood potty habits and temper tantrums were filmed for posterity, and to line my parent's pockets.

Jon and Kate have regular speaking engagements. For years they have claimed financial hardship, even when it wasn't so, and asked for "love offerings." Now, though, they are reneging on their commitments to various churches who can not afford their new speaking fee, which some estimate at around $25,000 including first class air fare and accommodations.

They have approached talk shows, always expecting freebies in return. I remember seeing them on Dr. Phil. They had written in asking for "parenting advice." In return they received a free nanny (for a year) plus thousands of dollars worth of toys. On Ellen they received bikes. Oprah gave them nothing which, according to Jodi's sister, upset them. They expected more.

Expectations and a sense of entitlement; when is enough, enough?

I would not mind all the freebies Jon and Kate receive if they were honest about them. It's not about envy; it's about dishonesty and trying to make people believe one way when, in fact, the situation is drastically different. Jon and Kate can provide for their family the way millions of others do. They are not the only ones with a large family but not all large families think they deserve to be rewarded or taken care of and given to because of the number of kids they have. Jon and Kate do.

Ultimately I hope they are honest with the public and stop taking from those that are worse off than they are. I also hope that the show is canceled, sooner rather than later. Yearly updates would have sufficed, but the train wreck it's turned into is both a shame and a disappointment.

Paul Petersen, who established the organization "A Minor Consideration" to support child stars and other child laborers has written a piece imploring Jon and Kate to cease filming.

16 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Sherry10/1/2009

    I enjoyed the show when they were real honest people that believed God and the church would help them have these children. But she went from mommywood to Hollywood and the show went to hell in a handbasket as my Grandmother would say. I agree with the tummy tuck, after all a woman has every right to have her body back after child birth the men do not lose their figure. But all of the donations should have been re-donated to local childrens charities. She is not "real" anymore. The show has changed her and the children are the ones paying for it. It would have been nice to have let them live their lives and check in on them every 6 months for a 2 hour special. Some money in their pocket, and some nice family entertainment for us.

  • LALA7/10/2009

    THANKS FOR THE INFO. I WISH I WOULD HAVE READ THIS AND THE COMMENTS A YEAR AGO. I FEEL LIKE I WASTED A YEAR!

  • Dan5/26/2009

    Having grown up in a family with 10 children I don't see why everyone says Kate is so fantastic. I grew up in the 60's. Both of my parents worked full time on different shifts so that someone would be home with us. My parents still had time to volunteer for scouts, little league, PTA and so on. I never heard my mom whine and complain how hard it was to raise 10 kids. We didn't have nannys and helpers, my parents did it all. I just don't see why these 2 idiots should be so looked up to. Every day parents raise their families and don't use their own children to make money off it. Shame on you Jon and Kate...

  • leenda5/22/2009

    what on earth is this woman going to do when all of her rugrats get on a school bus one morning and don't come home till the afternoon?? I don't think she is interesting enough to keep this one going all by herself. She will have to figure out another scam!

  • mom of four4/15/2009

    At first I enjoyed the show. Raising even one child can be a jobe in itself! But over time I became troubled. Especially when I saw so many people "helping" Kate an no thanks in return. Yes, singing at their door at Christmas time was Kates way of saying thank you but if it were me, I would have liked at least a thank you card. When I heard her say something on the order of having the 2 people from the show that helps women improve their wardrobes I KNEW she was in it for the swag. I was so angry I turned off the TV. After that I watched re-runs with a different "eye". This woman is in it for the goods not for the children. If all I have read about her is true, then I feel bad for her children. As it is, I many not be the cleanest homemaker in the world but I would rather spend time with my kids than clean the fridge!! Kate and Jon need to cut this out and go back to being parents with all that entails including sitting at the table after the kids are in bed and figuring out h

  • mom of twins2/16/2009

    I am a mom of twins and although I do no have as many children as the Gosselin's do, it has been a struggle just the same. I really enjoy the kids and the husband Jon, but she drives me crazy!!!! I just watched their most recent show and felt embarrassed for him when once again she "scolded" him for doing something she did not approve of. Is he one of the children or her partner? I would not want to or could I embarrass the man in public or private the way she does. Is her way the only right way? Also, I agree with the others regarding all their "outings". We would have loved to have taken our 2 children to many of the places they have been, but financially, we couldn't. I guess if I had 6 more at the same time it would have been a different story....

  • Your name getrealkate12/30/2008

    Watching this show is just unreal. Sick of seeing perfectly dressed kids going on wonderful outings. And any mother who throws a fit because her kids spill ice cream on thier clothes or get grass stains on them is living in a bubble. And the GERM thing. Get over it Kate! Especially with 8 kids. And please, please treat your husband with a little respect. Every week Jon is shown bathing and dressing the kids and Kate does nothing but complain because he put the wrong socks on the kids.
    The show needs to go. Kate's personality is enough to cancel the show and Jon doesn't look to happy lately.

  • lisa12/20/2008

    Unfortunatly there are a lot of people that are still not seeing the real truth behind these people and I can't understand it. It is so clear that J&K are using those children for their own financial gain. I wonder how much of that money will be left for those kids whenever they get older. kate is the one that I have the most trouble with. I feel that she does play favorites btween the kids. It seems that Mady and Cara are the least favorites, and probably because they are not the main money makers. I hope and pray that J&K will get over their greediness and stop this thing before it gets so bad that those kids are damaged for the rest of their lives.

  • rkb030511/4/2008

    I do still watch the show every week, however, it is not the same show as in the beginning. I found it much more interesting and realistic when it was a "normal" couple with lots of kids, trying to budget and get through every day life. Now every week they are at some amusement park or resort, getting special treatment with everything they do. I don't think being in front of the cameras is great for the kids, but, they have found a way to make a living and provide for all 8 of their kids, and stay home with them at the same time. Who knows if they go out looking for freebies, or if they are offered? It would be hard to turn down all that free stuff. I read the blog about Aunt Jodi, and was wondering why Beth hasn't been on lately. Anyway, I am a little disenchanted, too.

  • Constance Wise10/25/2008

    So true, I have watched and have become just where I turn it off.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.