Some people are against cloned meat. Some people are not convinced that cloned meat is safe. Many don't believe there is a valid need for cloned meat. Surveys have been done that show a significant amount of people refuse to eat cloned meat. Will people turn vegan to avoid consuming cloned meat and products derived from cloned animals? Will people insist cloned products be specially labeled? What will happen?
Let's take a look at the issues regarding cloned meat. What are scientists saying? What are people saying?
Why Produce Cloned Meat
The idea behind cloned meat, is to produce higher quality meat. With cloning, scientists can take ideal animals and clone them for the meat industry. In addition, animals can be cloned that will require less feed in order to produce the same amount of meat.
Cloning animals is expensive. People will most likely not be eating the cloned animals themselves, but the cloned animal's offspring. Scientists and the FDA claim that eating meat and milk products from cloned animals proposes no risk to those who eat it.
There are approximately six hundred cloned animals in the United States at this time. These cloned animals will most likely be used for breeding.
Safety Concerns of Cloned Meat
One of the big safety concerns of cloned meat is the unknown. Some of the cloned animals come out fine. Others do not. Some cloned animals die young and some tend to be sickly. Some cloned animals die before they are even born. What about the cloned animals that are born and grow up appearing normal? Can we be sure that they are indeed normal? Some scientists are concerned that we simply do not know what abnormalities to look for. There is concern that these abnormalities could pose a health risk to people who eat them. There is also concern that undetected abnormalities in cloned animals could pose a health risk to the animals themselves by leaving them susceptible to disease.
Livescience.com has a great article about some of the safety concerns of cloned meat and milk.
Animal Cruelty
Animal rights activist's point out that cloned animals are still living creatures. The cloned animals and the offspring of the cloned animals would still undergo the same treatment that non-cloned animals go through.
Friends of Animals, an animal rights group that is against cloned meat. They are not alone in their stance against cloned meat. Many animal rights groups consider cloned animals to be inhumane due to the fact that many cloned animals suffer from birth defects and diseases. According to animal rights groups, the high incidents of cloned animals with health problems is a source of needless animal cruelty and suffering.
Surveys of Consumers
According to The International Food Information Council, fifty percent of Americans are against cloned meat. A Google search on the internet on "Who would eat cloned meat?" brings back many results of consumers who say they would not eat cloned meat.
The International Food Information Council and many scientists believe that consumers will accept cloned meat once they are more educated on the process of cloning and the safety of cloned meat.
Will Cloned Meat Become Accepted?
No one knows the future, but my guess is that the issue of cloned meat is going to continue to be a heated topic for quite sometime. I have read heard many people vow that they will become vegan if cloned meat is not labeled. I have my doubts that every person will stick to the their vow. I do think that some people will get used to the idea of cloned meat and will eat it without much of a thought. I do not think that cloned meat will ever be fully accepted. There is a large group of consumers that are animal rights activists and organic activists. Animal rights activists will never accept cloned meats. Most organic activists do not believe in un-natural alterations to food and will not accept cloned meat.
Cloned meat sounds like something from a science fiction novel, but never the less it is here. Like it or not, it has become a reality.
Sources:
www.fda.gov/bbs/topics/NEWS/2008/NEW01776.html
www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/chi-080113meat-story,1,7659931.story
www.livescience.com/health/080109-animal-cloning.html
www.wate.com/Global/story.asp
www.friendsofanimals.org/programs/animal-rights/Mad_Science.htm
www.bio-medicine.org/medicine-news/EU-Considers-Allowing-Cloned-Meat--Milk-on-Market-19053-2/
www.ific.org/food/biotechnology/index.cfm
Published by RK
- What a Week it Was... (01-18-08 Edition)The following is a recap of some of the events of the week that I found to be interesting, humorous and/or disgusting.
Cloning Horses Takes Steps Forward in 2006In a long road from the cloned sheep Dolly, there have been horses successfully cloned. Their famous donors are well known. - Humans and the Natural World: Is it Necessary for Humans to Care for Nature?An essay addressing the idea of human interactions with nature. Should we be more sympathetic to the needs of nature, or continue down our path's of insolence and litter?
- What the Heck is Organic Food, Anyway?"Organic" has become such a catchphrase that it has entered the vernacular of the everyday American to almost everyday use. It's a word of which many people believe they know the meaning, but few do. Some frequently a...
- Gradually Going OrganicWould you like to experience the nutritional and taste advantages of eating organic foods? Are you wondering what foods to select, and how to shop for them frugally? Here are five good tips to help you add more natura...
- FDA Says Cloned Animals for Food Are Safe : Health, Ethical and Moral Dilemmas
- Cloned Meats
- Turning My Back on FDA Approved Cloned Meat
- Should Domestic Livestock Be Cloned?
- FDA Approves Cloned Cattle, Pigs, Goats for Food
- A Glassful of Cloned Milk
- BREAKING NEWS - FDA Says Cloned Meats Safe




9 Comments
Post a Commentgood article. sad to think about.
Very informative and well written. I have to agree with you that the issue is not one that will be generally accepted anytime soon. Great job on this!
I doubt I would eat it, who knows what could happen if you ate it, it is just too freaky!
Very well done! I am really sickened by the thought of what all we are cloning now. I remember when the lamb was cloned and everyone freaked out on it, and we all were assured it would go no further. Yeah right! Something is bound to go wrong with this, just like with everything else that is so good one year, and killing us all the next. Well done Bobbie!
Very well researched article. I'm uneasy about the thought of eating cloned meat at this time.
I wish people would stop playing God. I agree with Daniel; even if cloning is perfected something will happen, a disease maybe, and people will become really sick. Great reporting!
Great article. And for the record--HELL NO!! I will NOT eat cloned meat. Let the FDA eat it and then get back with us.
Good article. I think if cloning is perfected to where the animals are all healthy and all genetically the same, something will happen, a disease or something, and we will learn why nature does not naturally clone us. Variety, even within species is what make an eco system flexible and perpetuating.
Good article! I think a hundred years from now, we'll look back on thinking that eating cloned meat is a good idea and we'll shudder...