Withholding TV and Video Games is a Good Alternative to Spanking

Who Needs Spanking? We've Got TV and Video Games

Allison
A lot of people say that parents need to go back to spanking their kids, because kids are so out of control these days and need discipline. Parents complain that they should be allowed to spank their kids; teenagers complain that kids are acting like spoiled brats and need a good smacking to make them behave. Well I won't argue with the fact that we need more discipline. But we don't need spanking, and we shouldn't. Spanking can result in lasting emotional and psychological trauma, and plenty of kids have turned out fine without it. We shouldn't have to use corporal punishment, not when we have something much more effective. Something our parents didn't have when they were kids.

We have TV, we have video games, we have computers, and we have phones. Parents have the means to control these things and use them as tools of discipline.

To put it simply, you take it away when the kid misbehaves, and offer extra privileges as a reward to motivate kids to behave. Take the PS3 away when Johnny throws a tantrum in CVS. Tell Suzie if she's a good girl, she can stay up half an hour later to watch a special episode of her favorite show on Wednesday night.

One thing you can use is the V-chip, or other forms of TV parental control. Now, this is normally used to block kids from watching bad stuff, but you can just as easily set the V-chip to block Nickelodeon and Cartoon Network. Say your little girl loves Hannah Montanna. Wouldn't it suck for her if you set your parental controls to block that show for three weeks? That would sting a lot more than being whacked on the butt.

You could also set Playstation parental controls to require a password for certain ratings. It would be really simple to set it so your kid could only play Early Childhood games.

There's also software that allows parents to see what their kids are doing online, as well as block certain websites. You could just say "no internet for a week," and use the software to make sure the kid isn't going online when he or she isn't supposed to, or you could block their favorite websites as a punishment.

I see these types of punishments are more effective, and they're also effective deterrents. I mean, if you tell your kid what's in store if they don't behave, the kid will probably choose to behave in order to keep their precious video game privileges.

Published by Allison

I am currently a student at Northeastern University. I love to write, as well as a few other things. I'm a political science major and hope to run for office someday, but if that doesn't work I have been tol...  View profile

3 Comments

Post a Comment
  • AussieMum8/12/2008

    Yeah, but what do you do when you've got a kid (like mine) who has no interest whatsoever in being online, playing video games, playstation etc, watching telly etc. I swear if it wasn't for the occasional wellaimed smack or two, I'd be reduced to issueing threats of 'no chores' or 'do that again and I'm gonna make you go out this weekend!' Am I supposed to punish her by making her watch tv or what?!? Actually with a lot of the twaddle they put on tv these days that might be my best option!

  • Denny Jacques5/22/2008

    I don't agree that properly applied spanking is traumatic. As for your ideas about loss of privileges, those are all very good, but when I was a kid and I misbehaved, I lost privileges AND got spanked, not one or the other!

  • Sylvia Cochran4/25/2008

    Hmmm...I don't know...I understand that you make the point that a loss of privileges works better than spanking, but to my mind you are looking at discipline as a reactive process which it should not be.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.