Throughout the story you see Elisa physically and mentally steel herself to take on the role of a woman during war. She's proven herself capable of doing hard labor, donning the garb of a man, and assessing situations that weren't considered to be part of a woman's role. Ultimately it's her husband's refusal to accept her in a capacity that goes outside her gender role, that stalemates her from becoming more, and only in war where things aren't normal, can she finally realize her need to live outside what's socially accepted.
Steinbeck foresaw a nation headed to war, and the trials and tribulations that our nation's women would endure. Winston Churchill, then just a member of the British House of Commons, also foresaw the coming war in Europe after Chamberlain's open acceptance of Nazi Germany's terms at the Munich Conference. "You were given a choice between war and dishonor. You chose dishonor and you will have war."(Vail, John J., Pg 18) Czechoslovakia who could've easily bested Germany on the field follow both it's Western contemporaries, France and Great Britain, who were willing to risk anything for peace. "We would not be understood by Europe and the world if we provoked the war now. The Nation must endure," President Edvard Benes to his countrymen. (Gatzke, Hans. Pg 214)
Steinbeck's main character in Chrysanthemums, Elisa Allen is representative of all women who took on traditionally male roles in World War I and have now begun to realize that they might have to return to a country at war. Elisa shows this through her appearance and station in life. She's a farmer's wife making her part of the typical middle-class family of the time. She's shown as hardworking, but not outside of her own gender role. She does light gardening, but she doesn't participate in the harder farm work which is left to hired hands. Her garb is distinctly masculine, and is referred to in the work as a "costume" although she's pretending to be someone she's not with her "man's black hat pulled low down over her eyes, clod-hopper shoes, and a figured print dress almost completely covered by a big corduroy apron..." Her age is also appropriate as she would've been young enough to take on many of the male-dominated work positions that would've arose during WWII. Her mentality also lends itself that she'd been open to taking on a non-traditional position because during her conversation with the beggar about living in the wagon. He rejects her notion, by saying, "It ain't the right kind of a life for woman." She later tries to regain her composure and further cement that she's ready to take on issues that aren't considered feminine in nature, when she speaks to her husband about the prize fights. However her in-depth knowledge of what occurs evokes shock from her husband so she concedes to hide behind what was socially acceptable.
Elisa is seen throughout the majority of the story working steadily over the chrysanthemums that grow in her front yard. The chrysanthemums themselves are symbolic of "the American Way of Life" by how they are treated and their outcome. At the time a woman was expected to marry, have children, and raise a family. In a way, the chrysanthemums are Elisa's children, she nurtures and cares for them on a daily basis. They're protect from outside forces by the little white fence that surrounds them and she "destroys" any pests that would seek to harm them. They're the innocence, the sense of normality, that's lost during war. Just like how the chrysanthemums at the end of our story are misplaced, things such as "little fences" and "trips to town for dinner and a movie" don't exist in a world interrupted by war.
The world had been shattered by "The Great Depression of 1929," and in countries like World War I-torn Germany where unemployment rose from 1 million to 6 million people in the course of a year, promises, like those made by Adolf Hitler, were taken to heart. He spoke of a nation that would no longer have to pay the Allied forces, where every German would have a job, a nation that would grow strong again. Middle-class and the wealthy alike supported him due to his charismatic speeches and his disbelief in communism. To the ailing German people, he seemed like a godsend, a man that came from nothing and nowhere. Much like how the Beggar's Wagon emerges from the surrounding country-side.
The Beggar himself isn't very intimidating in appearance. His clothes are disheveled, and the donkey and dog he rides with are past their prime. Hitler himself was not wealthy and his position later in life can largely be contributed to the time he spent in the military, and his oratory gift. The Beggar also posses a highly persuasive nature and manages to secure Elisa's prized chrysanthemums from her through words, rather than actions. Just as Hitler managed to extort the Sudetenlands from Britain, France, and Czechoslovakia by being firm in his demands despite his lack of military power. Both the Beggar and Hitler prove themselves to be inhuman in their contempt for lives of others. The Beggar betrays himself when Elisa and her husband go into town only for her to discover that he'd gone and thrown the chrysanthemums, "the American Way of Life", in the road. Hitler passed laws against German Jews denying them the right to vote or marry non-Jews, and he later initiated the Kristallnacht (Night of Broken Glass) on November 9th where thirty thousand Jews were sent to prison camps after their businesses and synagogues were destroyed.
Published by Cynthia Leigh
Cynthia Leigh is a professional model, actress, writer, and costumer. She is currently under local and national representation through four agencies and is an Entertainment/Fashion Staff Writer for Goth... View profile
-
Chrysanthemums Are the #4 for Winter Flowers of North Texas
Mums are a favorite among North Texas gardeners. You can find them all over the region.
- One Step Forward for Women in the Unites States Military Forces Women in the United States have long fought for the right to be included in many facets of society, from the right to vote to breaking into professions like the medical field and other traditionally all-male fields
- A Historical Look at the Role of Art in an Ever-Changing World Nature versus technology is a timeless struggle in modernity; often art is the one medium which seeks to reveal the truth. Spurred by technology and the devastation of war, art explores the meaning of permanence in an...
- The Heroine in the Works of Chaucer Though few authors in Arthurian Romance spent time developing female characters, not all pieces were so deprived. Geoffrey Chaucer, in Troilus and Criseyde, presents a strong, independent, and self-interested heroine...
-
The Battle of Salamis: The True Story of an Ancient-World Naval Battle
Persia - an overwhelming colossus of military strength. While the Persian army ransacks their cities, a fragile collection of Greek ships prepares to defend their waters in the...
- Chrysanthemums-John Steinbeck
- William Faulkner, John Steinbeck and the Human Heart in Conflict Wiith Itself
- Literary Symbolism of Flowers in Willa Cather and John Steinbeck
- Worst World War II Movies Ever, Part One: Battle of the Bulge
- Conflict and Symbolism in Steinbeck's The Chrysanthemums
- An Explication of John Steinbeck's The Chrysanthemums
- Symbolism in John Steinbeck's The Chrysanthemums
|
|
5 Comments
Post a CommentAnd all this from the Salinas Valley - Steinbeck is inspirational, indeed! Good review...thanks, Cynthia. Michael
I read this in college, a long tme ago, I didn't remember it or the discussion of it being like this....guess I should go back and read it again. very thought provoking.
Great article-- keep writing!!!
Thanks. It was a research paper for my Fiction class.
This is really well-done.