How about WORST of Lists?
Why worst? Why not? Selecting the worst - or at least the weak from the top of the crop, can be fun. Not only does it leave what's behind that much better looking, but spotlights where - here a beloved television show - went occasionally wrong.
Star Trek: The Next Generation picked up - 80 years in show time & 18 years in real time - where original Star Trek left off. It won a Peabody Award for the episode, "The Big Goodbye", numerous accolades for cutting edge FX and in its last season snagged a Best Drama Emmy nomination - first ever for a syndicated television program. However, all those adventures sometimes weren't anything to write home to Earth about.
Here's five of the dopiest, clumsiest or just plain silly of the 179 episodes of that usually superb sci-fi TV show.
1. Angel One - First Season
Commander Riker is "feminized" - nuff said?
Enterprise journeys to planet Angel One - where women rule society. While, it's laudable exploring such a social construct, the episode is forced and plays comic when it tries to be socially experimental or relevant. Perhaps it's a case of good idea, bad execution, because it doesn't work for me. At one point, Jonathan Frakes must don a frilly nightgown to fit in with the more feminine males of the culture. Co-stars must have ribbed him for months afterwards!
2. The Dauphin - Second Season
Wesley falls for a "creature" - so bad it's almost good!
The Enterprise takes a future ruler of an alien race back home. She's a beautiful young human looking girl in all respects. But don't let that fool you! In reality she's, well she's everything! Her race shape shifts, so the beauty whom Wesley meets is just one of many forms she can assume. There are loads of unintentional laughable moments, especially the doe eyed looks Wesley flashes his alien love, along with a helium voiced morphin Granny Nanny who must be seen to be believed!
3. Hero Worship - Fifth Season
Boy worships Data after all die on his ship, but himself.
It's as touchy feely annoying as it sounds. What may have been a poignant exploration of a child's loss and an android's necessary nurturing of a wounded boy plays stilted and just boring. Upon a recent viewing I gave it a chance to redeem itself, but alas it wasn't to be. I feel the flat acting from the boy guest star is at least partially to blame.
4. Quality of Life - Sixth Season
Data rescues cybernetic probes from death, because "They're alive! ALIVE!"
A "life where we least expect it" episode that's Star Trek's trademark. This may have been a fascinating cerebral exercise about sentient life, exploring an intelligence apart from humanity, instead it absolutely flops. Maybe the clunky design of the "exocomps" - robotic probes which exhibit life signs is one reason it's bad. Look closely at cast members, including the nearly always marvelous Patrick Stewart as Captain Picard. His facial expressions in certain scenes display a "What garbage this is!" An episode I immediately flick off when I stumble upon it on TV.
5. Force Of Nature - Seventh Season
Global Warming is proven now, but this metaphor still blows bad wind on us all.
An alien brother and sister scientist team claim warp drive engine outputs from Starships "injure the fabric of space." OK. So the very reason why many love Star Trek and science fiction - advanced ships traveling faster than light is now off limits? I'll buy that for a dollar! Seriously, the green themed, environmentally conscious story isn't lost on me, and it's laudable for that, however the story it hinges upon is pedestrian at best and totally forgettable at worst. Maybe, Starfleet should invest in StarGates? Hey! What about Hyper Drive which Han Solo's Millennium Falcon uses?
Thanks to Tom Lobascio for his invaluable contribution to this article.
Published by Will Stape
Will is an Emmy Award nominated screenwriter. He also writes extensively for magazines and the web. Will penned episodes for the TV shows, Star Trek: The Next Generation & Star Trek: Deep Space Nine.... View profile
- The Star Trek Experience in Las VegasA review of The Star Trek Experience museum and ride at the Hilton in Las Vegas.
Review of Star Trek: Vanguard - Summon the ThunderThis is a review for Summon the Thunder. This novel is the second in an original novel series from Pocket Books called Star Trek: Vanguard. This series takes place in the tim...
Star Trek to Return for the Eleventh Time The sci-fi hit Star Trek is to return to a movie theatre near by Christmas Day 2008. This will be the eleventh installment of the oh so popular space adventure.- The Ethics of Star Trek by Judy BaradThe Ethics of Star Trek is a serious examination of ethical concerns and considerations that take specific Star Trek episodes as its starting point.
Star Trek's Gene Roddenberry was a Big HippieStar Trek was groovier than Austin Powers back in the day. In charge of it all was head hippy: Gene Roddenberry.
- Why Did Star Trek: Enterprise Fail?
- Star Trek Composer Jay Chattaway Strikes a Chord
- Star Trek Captains / James T. Kirk
- 33 Quotes from Star Trek Actor Patrick Stewart
- If You like Star Trek, Your Stupid!
- Star Trek Casting That Almost Happened
- Dawn Brown Interview: Watchmen Costume Illustrator & Star Trek Film Set Designer
- Sexy alien rulers may be shape shifters
- Male Starship Commanders may be forced to wear frilly nightgowns
- Starships may damage space and end exciting stories.





23 Comments
Post a CommentI have to disagree with you on your first three. Instead, what about "Birthright" 1&2? Klingons running through the forest. BORING.
"Angel One" is one of my favorites, being a Riker fan. The show explored his playboy side in an extremely different way. The character and the actor were interested in challenging the norms of our society--as well as the ones on the show.
Any second season episode.
I have both series on V.H.S.
The first Star Trek, & Next Generation. I've seen all of both, many,many times. Haven't really come across a bad one yet,really . I'll let you know when I do .
RJ - Get your ignorant head outta your globally warm butt & read:
Global warming is an increase in the temperature of Earth's near-surface since the mid-20th century & its projected continuation. According to 2007 Fourth Assessment Report by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), global surface temperature increased 0.74 ± 0.18 °C (1.33 ± 0.32 °F) during 20th century. Most observed temperature increase since middle of 20th century is caused by increasing greenhouse gases, which result from burning of fossil fuel and deforestation. Scientific consensus is global warming is occurring.
Global Warming is not proven at all liar. They had to change what they called it to "climate change" because of what a farce it is. I know this is a 3 year old article but it shows how sick the global warming cultists are including the writer of this article.
what's wrong with for once giving women empowerment? Angel One was great!
Love the show, but yeah, soome of these episodes could have been better. You're right, there aren't enough "worst of" lists. Need to work on one myself.
The worst episode in the series was "Sub Rosa"
Any list of worst TNG eps is full of fail if Sub Rosa isn't #1.
Personally I thought Journey's End was THE wors TNG EVER!! C'mon, Wesley going all bad a**, and suddenly the geek-out kid who wanted nothing more than to STEP onto the bridge turns out to have been doing nothing but trying to please his deceased father. That's crap! In one awefull episode they took the character of Wesley Crusher and ruined it forever.