Writing Tip: Phrasal Adjectives and Hyphens

Tara
While responding to an author's query regarding the correct use of a hyphen, I thought the following thoughts:

Hey! Maybe others are wondering the same thing!

Hey! Maybe I should share this kind of information with these others!

Thus begins my series of writing tips.

Phrasal adjectives and hyphens

Phrasal adjectives are also known as compound modifiers.

What I'm talking about:
Sometimes two words appear before a noun that describe the noun, a two-word adjective. To avoid confusion, often a hyphen needs to be added to these two words to signify that together they make up the adjective. Most of the time little confusion exists, but sometimes it does.

For example:
Crazy cat lady vs. Crazy-cat lady. The first tells the reader that the cat lady is crazy; the second says that she is a lady who likes crazy cats.

Nasty looking glass vs. nasty-looking glass. The first tells the reader that the mirror is nasty; the second says that the glass looks nasty.

Fast moving van vs. fast-moving van. The first tells the reader that the moving van is fast; the second says that a van is moving fast.

Fancy pants store vs. fancy-pants store. The first tells the reader that the pants store is fancy; the second says that the store sells fancy pants.

Exceptions to this rule are proper nouns and verbs ending in "ly."

Proper nouns
I like Cyber Cafe coffee.
I like Hugh Jackman movies.
These do not need hyphens. Ambiguity is basically nonexistent.

Verbs ending in "ly"
Fiscally-conservative Republican = wrong. (The hyphen, not the person).

The "ly" already modified the "fiscal," so no need for a hyphen. It's redundant, such as saying it was 2:00 a.m. in the morning. (Bleeding-heart liberal needs the hyphen.) And ambiguity is once again unlikely.

Correct: Exceptionally beautiful wife

While we're on the subject of little dashes that appear between two letters, let me introduce you to the lesser-known en dash. You may have come across these before, and, if you noticed them, you likely thought they were a hyphen in a different font. Nope. These longer dashes are en dashes, and serve an important purpose.

The en dash is most often used to connect numbers, depending on publishing company preference (I lived there from 2000-2002, the party is from 7:00-9:00), but they are used to connect words as well. En dashes are appropriate for compound adjectives when one of the adjectives is an open compound, meaning one of the adjectives is two words that must remain together.

For example:
Pre-civil war era vs. pre-civil war era. The first indicates the war era was before civil; the second says era was before the civil war.

The hyphen incorrectly connected "pre" with only "civil," when "pre" needed to connected to "civil war." Use the en dash as well when two two-word adjectives are combining to form a compound modifier (red state-blue state dynamic).

Summary:
Modify compound adjectives with a hyphen to avoid confusion, except with proper nouns and words ending in "ly."
Use an en dash when creating a compound adjective with 1+2, 2+1, 2+2 words.

Now that you've learned this, tell all of your friends, and anyone you meet (to make new friends).

Published by Tara

I am a copy editor. I sometimes write articles. I sometimes give grammar advice. Take this advice if you'd like. Always consult a proper grammar manual, and feel free to ask questions.  View profile

3 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Tara8/8/2010

    Hi John. I'm assuming you have one purse that matches another article of clothing and not two purses, one black and one white. If you have just one purse, I think most people would know what you mean with either spelling (with or without hyphens), but I'd go with the hyphenated "black-and-white," mostly because this is how Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary spells it but also because this indicates that you are in fact talking about only one purse. Hope this helps!

  • John Eakins8/8/2010

    Tara,
    Which of the following phrases are correctly written:
    I had a matching black and white purse.
    I had a matching black-and-white purse.
    Thanks

  • Tara6/21/2010

    CORRECTIONS AND CLARIFICATIONS: (1) The heading "Verbs ending in 'ly'" should be "ADVERBS ending in 'ly.'" Both "fiscally" and "exceptionally" are adverbs. (2) Formatting of en dashes was lost. Sorry. The following should have en dashes, not hyphens: 2001*en*2002, 7:00*en*9:00, and the second "pre*en*civil war." (3) CHICAGO MANUAL OF STYLE prefers "pre-civil-war" (3 hyphens) to pre*en*civil war and the like when using general terms. If you have a two word proper noun that should be capitalized, however, such as the American Civil War, an en dash should be used: pre*en*Civil War. (4) This is not a complete source on en dashes (or otherwise). Please consult a proper grammar manual for furthur uses.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.