Take, for example, these match-ups for the 2007 bowl season (taken from ESPN.com):
Cincinnati vs. Southern Miss- And the Bearcats got royally screwed why?
New Mexico vs. Nevada- Although I find in interesting New Mexico's kicker has no ACL in his plant leg and still went 26-of-29 on FGs, that's the only thing I find interesting here.
BYU vs. UCLA- Mismatch, plain and simple. BYU deserves better.
Boise State vs. East Carolina- See BYU
Boston College vs. Michigan State- Really? The 8th-place team from the Big Ten against an ACC Championship game participant?
However, these screw-ups are nothing compared to what REALLY pisses me off:
#1- USC vs. Illinois: *cough* blowout *cough*...Juice Williams hasn't seen a defense as scary as what the Trojans bring to the table. Illinios-Hawaii would be better suited, or the Fighting Illini against maybe Virginia Tech. Screw tradition, I'm young.
#2- Georgia vs. Hawaii- So, arguably the hottest team in the nation, albeit 2 or 3 weeks off, can't face the other arguably hottest team in the nation, USC? Instead, we have a top-5 Georgia team against unproven Hawaii? While I will watch this game because it intrigues me and I want to see how the mid-major does, Georgia vs. USC would be so much more fun.
#3- Missouri vs. Arkansas- See #4
#4- Virginia Tech vs. Kansas- Okay, let me think here: Missouri was #1 in the BCS before Saturday, and are currently two spots ahead of #8 Kansas in the BCS standings. Oh, and the Tigers beat the Jayhawks.
Somebody should be fired. Right the heck now. What are you thinking, Orange Bowl morons?!?!
Now, some games will be a boatload of fun to watch, such as Arizona State-Texas, Tennessee-Wisconsin, Oklahoma-West Virginia, and Clemson-Auburn. But the rest of the games either suck or aren't that interesting. Anybody getting amped for Colorado-Alabama? What about Fresno State-Georgia Tech?
To finish this rant, here are my solutions to this problem:
First, get rid of bowl tie-ins. All bowls should be set in an order of best-to-worst, in terms of payout/date played (if there's a tie, flip a coin or something). Then have each bowl select the best possible two teams from whoever's available after the BCS bowls get their choices.
Next, eliminate the crappiest 10 bowls. A standard should be set for college football, and 6-6 ain't it, I don't care if when you were 6-5 the Rose Bowl was a slight possibility (UCLA) or if at 5-6 your bowl streak was in jeopardy (Louisville, who didn't make it). If this is about money, stop boring people to death and pay attention to the ratings. Give the deserving teams their shots, including smaller schools from mid-major conferences, and let what the fans want happen. (Which would mean a playoff, but I spoke of that last post)
College football: The only sport that may not listen to its fans at all.
Published by Caleb Rule
Having graduated cum laude with a B.A. in Mass Communication from Georgia College & State University, Caleb hopes to do video production and editing for a professional Atlanta sports team one day. He is curr... View profile
- LSU Vs. Florida 2009 Game Time Should Draw Huge AudienceThe game of the week in college football is the LSU vs. Florida game, as it pits two teams against each other not only looking for a conference championship, but a National Title as well.
- Dixie State College in St. George, UtahLearn about DIxie State College in St. George, Utah. St. George is rated the 6th best city in the USA!
2009 College Football Preseason Top 25A preseason ranking of the 25 best college football teams for 2009.- 2008-2009 NCAA College Football Bowl Previews and Predictions Part IIThis article previews the NCAA College Football Bowl Games occurring between 31 December 2008 and 8 January 2009. Many great matchups, culiminating with the BCS National Championship on January 8th.
Shooter Identified in Virginia Tech MassacreDebates over Virginia Tech's handling of the information and the age-old debate over the right to bear arms are just the beginning in the aftermath of the Virginia Tech shootings.
- The Bottom Ten/Bowl Game Edition
- 2008-2009 College Football Bowl Schedule Highlighted by National Championship Game...
- Preseason College Football Top 10
- 2008-2009 BCS Bowl Game Review and Upcoming Predictions
- NCAA Approves Four New Bowl Games, Increasing the Lineup to 32 Games
- What Does it Take to Win a Super Bowl?
- North Georgia College and State University Dahlonega School Review


3 Comments
Post a Comment2 bowl games feature rematches from this season- UCLA-BYU and Purdue-Central Michigan. Not even fans of those schools can get excited about that crap.
yep we only consider some matchups as screw ups because of the BCS. Presidents of schools have stated that they can't schedule set for a playoff system, too much money is wrapped up in advertising these bowls. They should still do a plus 1 and see how that goes then down the road think to get a plus 2 started. We'll have to wait and see, but a true playoff like Div. II will never happen. Not for a long time anyways
Agreed, it's time for a playoff.